An interesting hand to be sure. Distribution makes both the East & South hands much stronger than point count would indicate. The East hand is especially strong with a Quick Trick count of 3.5 (standard is 2.0) & a Loser Count of 3 (standard is 7). I can picture the following auction:
Pass - 1C (possibly only three clubs & 13-21 points) - 1S (5+ spades & 8+ points - tentative plan to bid diamonds next) - Pass (could raise clubs but that would imply a five card suit - cannot bid NT which would promise a spade stopper - pass for now might be best choice) - 2S (a simple raise) - 3C (six or more clubs & strong enough to bid again even though partner has promised nothing)
At this point NS should probably stop bidding. They are vulnerable. Looks to me like they deserve to lose 4 tricks in a diamond contract & 5 tricks in a spade contract (if West finds a diamond Ace lead). Penalty ladder for going down Vulnerable & Doubled: 200 (1st trick) - 500 - 800 - 1100. Down two would give EW more points than if EW were to bid & make game.
West, upset at not being able to tell partner with their first call that they had some points, should now raise to 5C. I see no way to get to slam in clubs from here except via a Ho Chunk "I feel lucky." bid.
An experienced pair might
find the slam if on their second bid East opts to cue bid 3S. The cue bid might
lead to a sequence where East finds out about partner's diamond Ace.
No comments:
Post a Comment