Partners needed for January 5, 2022 at 9:00 a.m.
- Molly Koranda if Terry Schnapp is not available
- BBO ID: molly_kora
- email address is: molly_koranda@yahoo.com
Partners needed for January 5, 2022 at 9:00 a.m.
Hope you don’t mind but I’m going to do more than answer your question!
Responder was correct to bid 1 ♦️ and NOT 1 ♥️. I always tell people to bid up the line and
NOT to bypass a 4-card ♦️ suit to show a bad
4-card Major. If partner with an opening hand can bid the 4-card major and get
the lead to come into his hand he will usually get an extra trick!!! That is
certainly very worthwhile in bridge competition. We teach players in BB1 to
look for a major But we NEVER teach them to be the one to bid a major 1st. 1 ♦️ is 100% forcing so let your partner bid the Major and
become a winner!!!!
Now on to the bidding by South. S, you have a very clear cut 1 ♥️ overcall. You have a good 5-card suit and 7 or more points and you must bid 1 ♥️ to give your partner a chance to raise you or maybe make further bidding by the opponents difficult or even help your partner make the right opening lead. You do NOT have enough points to overcall at the 2-level. A 2-level overcall in my book is 11+ points, but Audrey teaches you must have 13 points.
See
You At The Tables,
Glenna
Holding a long minor suit, NT is typically the “strain” of choice. In this particular scenario, however, North/South have only limited transportation between their two hands. That renders a NT contract a high risk proposition at best. Playing in NT, good defense could leave declarer unable to take more than one club trick.
The best contract NS could have found is 4H. The second call by South of 2H promises a 6-card heart suit. I would expect North to focus on the golden fit in hearts (6 + 2) & bid 3H (rather than 3C). I would expect South to subsequently raise to 4H. Looks to me like NS deserve to lose only the three missing Aces, making game.
Note: There are 5 “strains” in bridge : spades - hearts - diamonds - clubs - NT. These are also referred to as the 5 “denominations”. Many bridge players find it much easier to simply talk about the 5 “suits”, even though NT is of course not a suit.
Ain’t
bridge a great game?
Question: This hand made 11 tricks. How do you bid this when the majors are short?
Glenna:
1st, I should say North should know their partner has few points and probably
not a suit of their own. The 2nd thing they should think is that the opponent
opened the bidding and N has 20 some points in his hand so partner will NOT
raise him. There are two ways to get South to bid: 1. N could bid 2 ♠️ showing ♥️ and a minor. When S bids, N
would correct to some number of ♥️. The other method is to make
a take out double (TOX) which S must respond to and the N could bid 2 ♥️ and S should realize his partner has a ton of points and I
would raise ♥️ even though, I have only 2.
N has game in his own hand, but must get partner’s cooperation and not
just leap off to 4—there could be a slam!
Hope
this helps,
Glenna
Question: Overcalls require four a suit. This overcall has clubs which is what was bid. Can one go to the second suit, hearts, for an overcall?
Vic:
An overcall in a suit promises a 5-card suit, NOT a 4-card suit. That makes a heart overcall inappropriate, despite the strength of the suit.
A Takeout DBL overcall promises “tolerance” in the unbid suits. A 4-card suit definitely meets the standard for tolerance. Many experienced players these days often have 3-card suits that they are comfortable making a Takeout DBL with. Hearts & Diamonds in the above example are both suits I would be comfortable making a Takeout DBL with. The singleton spade, however, does not meet the standard for tolerance by any stretch of the imagination. That makes overcalling with DBL also an inappropriate option.
Holding the above hand, I would simply clench my teeth & Pass. If I ultimately got a second chance to call, my second call would depend on what West and/or North had chosen to do. If West & North both Pass, of course, the auction is over & we will see how close East can come to taking seven tricks in clubs.
Ain't
bridge a great game?
Question: East is the balancing seat. When does East decide to bid to keep the auction going?
[Editor's Note: You are said to be “balancing” when you are in the pass out seat after a bid by your left-hand opponent (LHO).
West North East South
1♣ Pass Pass ?
In this example, South is in the balancing seat.]
Glenna:
E’s
hand does NOT qualify for interference. You should have a good 6-card suit or a
5-5 or 5-4 hand with all your points in your long suit. If E’s ♣️ were AKJTxx, he could bid 2 ♣️ , but should pass with this very, very bad hand. That is,
unless he wants to go down 500 or 800 against a 1NT contract! In the real
world, ♣️ would be doubled!!
Thanks,
Glenna
Question: Do you accept a transfer even if you suspect you will not have a golden fit?
Vic:
The quick answer to your question is a resounding YES.
Trusting your partner AND being a partner they can trust in return is essential to good bridge. So if partner asks you to do something, it is not your place to decide whether it is a good idea or not. Just trust that it IS a good idea & do it. If you should ultimately conclude that partner almost always makes bad decisions, get a new partner.
Having said that, I see that North in the above auction is a robot. I believe that the auction shown is an example of drastic miscommunication between robot & human. South apparently intends their 2NT bid to show a classic 2NT opening hand. South, however, is NOT Opener. South is Overcaller which changes everything.
I would interpret the 2NT overcall by South as an “Unusual NT” which is a very popular conventional call that promises 5 - 5 distribution in the two lowest unbid suits (clubs & hearts in this case). I believe that is how the robot interpreted the 2NT overcall as well.
That means the subsequent 3H bid by robot was NOT a transfer, but simply a suit preference bid telling South the robot liked hearts better than clubs. The miscommunication continued, resulting in a truly disastrous auction.
The
proper way for South to describe their hand to partner in the above auction is
a partnership agreement issue. But I do not expect many partners would agree
that the proper way to do so is by bidding 2NT.
Glenna:
I love the
bidding—great preemptive bidding!!!!
When your opponents do that to you, you should say nice bidding and move
on. You played the board against the wrong people—good bidders!!!
Question: Should W support partner’s overcall of a weak 2 H bid ?
Vic:
The 2S overcall by East promises a 5-card spade suit. The Law of Total Trump dictates that East should subsequently bid 4S.
Law of Total Trump: Do not be hesitant (even vulnerable) to compete up to the level of your total number of trump. More often than not, it will earn you a good board.
Ten
Trump = Ten Tricks = Four Level
Question: N opens 1 D and S passes. Hand went down 1. Should S bid 1NT in response to the 1 D?
Glenna:
South is obligated to bid if he has 6 or more points!!!! Passing with this hand
would normally incite the opponents to call the director! When your
partner opens, you are obliged to bid and this is a nice hand so perhaps South
misclicked?? 1NT should show 6-10 so this should be 2 NT showing 11 or 12. And,
of course, with 13-15 bid 3 NT. With 14 or more, look for slam!
Vic:
East (dealer): 1C (13 - 21 pts) (3+ clubs) (no 5-card major)
South: Pass
West: 1D (6+ pts) (4+ diamonds) (tends to deny 4+ hearts) (forcing)
North: Pass
East: 1S (4 spades) (denies 4 hearts)
South:
Pass
West:
3NT (to play) (denies a golden fit in spades)
(When you know, you go.)
All
Pass